A smart grid is a transactive grid.
- Lynne Kiesling
Consumer Power: Time-To-Drawer, A Home Energy Management Bubble, and The Need To Engage Consumers

Courtesy of Clean Techies, an interesting article on the power of energy consumers, specifically the need to engage consumers or risk watching the home energy management & energy information display industries fall flat.  Of course, we have long championed the need to engage consumers – this article gets close when it says “…onsumers might start viewing energy and the managing of it much as they do their bank accounts..” and it even goes on to discuss something we have also focused on that behavioral information created during these deployments can be valuable in and of itself.

“…Market drivers in the home energy management (HEM) space are indicative of any residential energy efficiency market –they pivot on energy efficiency measures and applications affecting the bottom line. Additionally, in the residential energy efficiency space –and more specifically HEM– consumer engagement and the promotion of energy efficiency and demand response (DR) will have to be the driving force in reducing capital expenditures (capex).

Consumer participation even trumps the market accepted differing channel paths that HEM vendors will penetrate while trying to supply more devices and create larger profit margins.

The current market-accepted winning business model to distribute energy information displays (EIDs) is by penetrating a utility’s customer channel into the home. This is the case in North America and even more so in the UK, where EIDs will be offered (in addition to smart meters) by British energy companies. Yet, the most challenging hurdle for the market to overcome –as a Pike Research senior analyst likes to say– will be the EIDs “mean time to drawer,” resulting in non-use of the device.

If consumer behavior does not change, and families do not begin to manage their energy via an EID, then crucial data will never be created, thereby hindering many potentially vital algorithms and tools built around consumer energy data in the future. The quicker the “mean time to drawer,” the higher the possibility that EIDs become vaporware –and the HEM market a “bubble,” as so many have suggested before.

But consumers might start viewing energy and the managing of it much as they do their bank accounts. Here, beyond simply increasing energy efficiency and residential DR for consumer benefits, consumer engagement will also create new revenue streams through increased data production.

The EID –whether consumer advocate groups like it or not– will provide insight to the behavioral and fiscal attributes of residential energy end-users. This data will enable two very powerful groups –advertising agencies and politicians– to make informed business and governing decisions. Where advertisers (i.e. Google) will sell us swimsuits when they glean that we have been heating our pool, legislatures and policy makers will carve out specific carbon pricing and renewable portfolio standards that level the playing field for those most affected: the utility industry, end-users, and the environment.

The result of increased energy efficiency and demand response in the residential sector has far-reaching implications through periphery benefits and the trickledown effect, also. One such case is lower customer service costs for utilities, which will force the hand of the regional public utility commission (PUC) to lower rates.

Customer service is one of the highest operational expenditure line-items on a utility’s balance sheet. This cost will be driven down because utility call-centers will be in lower demand. Rather than call the utility, consumers will have the power of information at their fingertips be it information about energy usage, basic FAQs, online databases or chat assistance over the internet.”

Yet, despite this clarion call (again) to bring consumers into the equation, we are greeted instead with the announcement of yet another smart(?) energy demand trade association, with nary a consumer represented:

“…To highlight the critical role of energy users in the Smart Grid, leading utilities, technology companies, and industry groups launched the Smart Energy Demand Coalition (SEDC) today at a press conference at the European Union’s Strategic Energy Technology Plan Conference. SEDC members include founding members eMeter and VaasaETT, as well as Landis+Gyr, EDF (EDF.FR), ENEL (ENEL.MI), Gas Natural Fenosa (BMAD: GAS), the Climate Group, Vodafone (LSE: VOD, NASDAQ: VOD), Universidad Comillas (Madrid), the European Smart Meter Investment Group, the Demand Response and Smart Grid (DRSG) coalition, The Peak Load Management Alliance (PLMA), Capgemini (Euronext: CAP), Entelios, Jouleasset, Schneider Electric (Euronext: SU), the ZigBee Alliance and Silver Spring Networks.

The SEDC is a not-for-profit industry association based in Brussels and consisting of utilities, electricity retailers, and providers of services and technologies related to demand response, energy efficiency, smart meters and smart grids. The Coalition is willing to share expertise and information with industry participants, regulators and policymakers, media and consumer associations regarding the deployment of smart meters and communications systems seeking to enable energy providers to offer their customers time-based rates with off-peak discounts, thereby allowing consumers to save on their electricity bills by varying their demand in response to price signals. Additional benefits are provided by smart grids, which automate substations and circuits used for electricity distribution….”

Perhaps it is indeed time to call for Consumer Power…



This entry was posted on Thursday, November 18th, 2010 at 2:00 pm and is filed under Uncategorized.  You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.  You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site. 

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


About This Blog And Its Authors
Grid Unlocked is powered by two eco-preneurs who analyze and reference articles, reports, and interviews that can help unlock the nascent, complex and expanding linkages between smart meters, smart grids, and above all: smart markets.

Based on decades of experience and interest in conservation, Monty Simus believes that a truly “smart” grid must be a “transactive” grid, unshackled from its current status as a so-called “natural monopoly.”

In short, an unlocked grid must adopt and harness the power of markets to incentivize individual users, linked to each other on a large scale, who change consumptive behavior in creative ways that drive efficiency and bring equity to use of the planet's finite and increasingly scarce resources.